2009

Senior Charity Cup Winners
League Cup Runners-up
Sawkill Cup Winners
Senior League Division 2 Runners-up
York Vale League Division 1 Runners-up

2008

York Vale League Division 2 Runners-up

2007

Senior League Premiership Champions
Senior League Division 3 Runners-up
Junior Charity Cup Winners
Pilmoor League Division 2 Champions

2006

Acomb Invitation Cup Winners
York Vale League Division 2 Runners-up

2005

Junior Charity Cup Winners
York Vale League Division 3 Runners-up

2004

Acomb Invitation Cup Winners
Frank Piercy Cup Winners
Myers & Burnell Cup Runners-up

2003

Senior Charity Cup Winners
Acomb Invitation Cup Winners

2001

Premier League Runners-up
Myers & Burnell Cup Winners
Senior Charity Cup Winners

2000

Premier League Runners-up
York Vale League Division 3 Champions
Senior Charity Cup Winners
Heworth Invitation Cup Winners
Prendergast Memorial Cup Winners
Black Sheep Yorkshire Champions Trophy Runners-up

1999

Senior League Premiership Champions
York Vale League Division 4 Runners-up
Myers & Burnell Cup Winners
Acomb Invitation Cup Winners
Senior League Indoor Winners

1998

Acomb Invitation Cup Winners
Senior Charity Cup Winners
U19 York Invitation Cup Winners

1997

Senior League Division 1 Runners-up
Acomb Invitation Cup Winners

1996

Acomb Invitation Cup Winners

1995

Senior League Division 2 Runners-up
Senior League Division 4 Runners-up
York Invitation Cup Winners
Senior Charity Cup Winners

1993

Senior League Division 2 Champions
Senior League Division 5 Runners-up

1992

NatWest U16 League Champions
NatWest U16 Zone Champions

1988

NatWest U16 League North Zone Champions
NatWest U16 League Runners-up
U16 Mitchell Intersport Knock-out Cup Winners

1987

Senior League Division 2 Runners-up

1986

Senior League Division 3 Champions
Junior Charity Cup Winners

1984

Senior League Division 5 Runners-up (2nd XI)
Ryedale Evening League Winners

1978

Senior League Division 3 Champions

1976

Senior League Division 4 Runners-up

1975

Senior League Division 5 Champions